When Emily Carranza of Sylmar first heard that Gov. Gavin Newsom announced he was commuting all 548 death sentences in California to life in prison, she felt upset and frustrated. Her cousin Gabriel Fernandez was brutally tortured and murdered by his mother and her boyfriend when he was 8 years old, and now one of his killers could see his sentence reduced.

Olivia Rubio, a cousin of Gabriel Fernandez, said Gov. Gavin Newsom “stabbed them in the back” by announcing he will commute all 548 death sentences in the state. (Photo courtesy of Jonathan Hatami)

To make matters worse, this week Carranza was shocked to learn that Isauro Aguirre, who was sentenced to death in Gabriel’s murder – his mom, Pearl Fernandez, received a life sentence without parole – had already been removed from San Quentin State Prison’s death row and relocated to Corcoran State Prison. 

In fact, as of May 28, 2024, all condemned inmates who were housed at San Quentin were transferred to high-security, general population prisons across the state to comply with Prop 66, the Death Penalty Reform and Savings Act, which voters passed in 2016 to speed up executions.

Carranza felt livid.

“My disappointment and hurt and betrayal has turned into anger,” said Carranza. “[Newsom] doesn’t care about California laws; he doesn’t care about the punishment[s] that [were] handed down. He just showed everybody – law enforcement, the judges, the families, the victims – that he does what he wants to do. … He says, ‘No more kings,’ but yet he’s acting like a king.”

On the west steps of the California State Capitol in Sacramento last week, 25 victim families were joined by legislators, district attorneys, law enforcement officers and victim advocates to speak out against the commutations and announce a planned legal challenge. Relatives also recounted the heartache of losing their loved ones and needing to fight for justice yet again.

The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation (CJLF), a nonprofit that supports public safety and victims’ rights, filed a lawsuit last weekend that seeks to block the mass commutations. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan J. Hochman announced he supports the lawsuit.

“We are asking the court to uphold the law, respect the sanctity of jury verdicts and protect the rights of victims,” said Anne Marie Schubert, president and CEO of CJLF. She explained that the legal challenge “involves two fundamental failures” – first, they claim Newsom didn’t follow the California law requiring the governor to notify district attorneys during the commutation process.

“Not a single phone call, not a single email, not a single letter to the district attorney[s] … whose offices actually prosecuted those cases,” she said. “Because prosecutors were left out, victims’ families were left in the dark. Many were horrified to learn about Newsom’s plans on the news.”

The lawsuit also challenges what Schubert described as “the governor’s abuse of executive power and his failure to examine every one of these cases individually,” she said.

“Can a blanket commutation without individualized review truly be a lawful exercise of executive power?” she asked. “The rule of law applies to everyone, including the governor.”

Decision to Pursue Mass Commutations

Newsom announced Nov. 5 that he was commuting “all [548] California death sentences to life without the possibility of parole,” stating he believes that “state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values.” Newsom instituted a moratorium on executions in 2019.

“California voters have voted to keep the death penalty on the books [in 2012 and 2016], and I respect that,” he wrote in an open letter announcing the commutations. “I recognize the limits of this clemency action, which does not repeal the death penalty.”

Rather, he noted, his action is “limited to commuting California’s current death sentences.”

Newsom described his decision to pursue mass commutations for all condemned prisoners as “among the most difficult of my career, not because I doubt its necessity for our state but because I know its announcement may surface excruciating memories for victims’ families,” he stated.

“I deeply respect the views of those who will strongly disagree with my decision, including some families of victims who have suffered the worst possible loss,” Newsom continued.

Among those surviving family members who strongly disagree is Mary Muscarella. On March 23, 1990, she dropped off her 8-year-old son Paul Bailey at Darby Avenue Elementary School in Northridge, just like any other weekday. But this time, she never got to see her son alive again.

Gregory Scott Smith, a recently fired teacher’s aide, abducted Paul shortly after drop-off. Later that same day, authorities discovered the boy’s remains in a remote area near Simi Valley. Smith had sexually assaulted Paul, strangled him to death and then set his body on fire.

After pleading guilty, Smith was sentenced to death in 1992 and has spent decades on death row. But Smith is now among 548 inmates who could have his sentence commuted to life in prison. 

“Paul was not just a name in a court file. He was a child. He had a family who loved him, a future ahead of him and an entire life that was taken away,” recounted Muscarella.

“Where does the voice of the voters fit into this decision?” she continued. “Where does the jury’s decision fit? And where is the consideration for the innocent lives that were taken?”

Muscarella wondered if Newsom was aware of the heinousness of the crimes involved.

“Did you consider the sheer terror and suffering Paul endured?” she asked. “We cannot change what happened to our loved ones, but we can demand that … their suffering is never minimized.”

In his letter, Newsom acknowledged the pain and suffering of victims and their families.

“The people sentenced to death in California caused indescribable suffering to victims, their families, communities and our state as a whole,” he wrote, adding that the “harm they inflicted persists across generations. …

“But as governor,” he continued, “I have concluded the state cannot morally kill them. …We can now let these offenders die in obscurity while we forever remember and honor their victims.”

Olivia Rubio, also a cousin of Gabriel Fernandez, said she feels that Newsom has “stabbed them in the back.”

“It’s hard for our family to go through this,” she said through tears, describing Gabriel as a “little boy full of life” when his mother took him away from the relatives who had been caring for him for years. Gabriel ended up being tortured for eight months by his mother and her boyfriend.

“We need to continue to fight,” she said. “We need to continue to be the voices for these children, because there [are] so many sex offenders [and] child abusers out there that we need to stop.”

Condemned Prisoners Transferred

The last execution carried out in California was in 2006, under then-Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger. In 2016, California voters passed Prop 66, which aims to: streamline and accelerate executions by limiting the appeals process; cut prison expenses by dismantling the single-person cells on death row; and mandate victim restitution by re-housing prisoners at general population, maximum-security prison facilities with work programs across the state.

According to the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, all condemned prisoners were removed from segregated death rows as of 2024 – the men out of San Quentin and the women from Central California Women’s Facility – and placed in 24 prisons across the state with lethal electrified fencing, where they will remain under strict security protocols.

Although the transfers did not change the prisoners’ death sentences, Carranza said she fears the inmates already being imprisoned in general population facilities may make it easier for the California Supreme Court to eventually side with Newsom.

If Newsom’s decision to commute all 548 inmates stands up to the upcoming legal scrutiny, it will be the biggest mass clemency in American history. But not all the sentences would necessarily be commuted. Four out of seven California Supreme Court judges would have to approve the commutations for individuals who were convicted of two or more felonies.

But many surviving relatives are hoping the death sentences will remain intact.

“It’s been almost 33 years since my sister’s been gone, and I will never get over her murder,” said Melissa Hernandez, whose sister Diana Contreras was robbed and murdered in 1993. “My life sentence is having to live without my sister Diana and Charles F. Rountree’s life sentence should [be to] remain on death row.”

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *